Saturday, November 21, 2026

Humanitarian assistance, security agendas and political turmoil; an impossible balance.

A few words  in the Montreal Gazette from Joanne Liu former president  (2013 to 2019) of Médecins sans Frontières (MSF) on her new book, a memoir, Ebola, Bombs, and Migrants: Humanitarian Crises in a Security Obsessed World; Dr.Liu perspective is relevant as her experience at the head of MSF coincided not only with the beggining of the breaking dow of a rules-based international order but also in the early stages of the transformation of MSF from a leading non-governmental provider of humanitarian and medical assistance into a juggernaut with a budget of billions, presence all over the world and a strong influence (hence with a stake in outcomes and responsiblity in consecuences) 0n  ongoing debates on global health and humanitarian action. 
Today, MSF embodies some of the contradictions of the humanitarian industrial complex and many of the shortcomings of western-based CSOs operating in   (cultural, political, religious) foreign lands. At the same time the space and ability to operate for smaller and independent civil society organizations has shrunk, regionally and at national level,  due to a combination of political and economical factors.


We added hyperlinks and additional reference material (from the blog and elsewhere) at the need.


‘We live in fear’: Montreal doctor’s memoir takes a hard look at international aid within the new world order
Dr. Joanne Liu begins with a bracingly honest look at her many years with Médecins sans frontières.

T'Cha Dunlevy

“Ebola, Kunduz, migrants.”

That’s how Dr. Joanne Liu sums up the lessons she learned in her six years as president of Médecins sans frontières, a.k.a. Doctors Without Borders, which inspired the title of her new book Ebola, Bombs, and Migrants: Humanitarian Crises in a Security Obsessed World, co-authored by André Pratte.


An updated translation of L’Ebola, les bombes et les migrants, published in 2024, the eye-opening read takes a hard, honest look at the reality of international aid within the new world order since 9/11.


“The basic premise of the book is that since 9/11, we live in fear,” Liu said Wednesday from her office at McGill University, where she is a professor at the School of Population and Global Health and director of the Pandemic and Emergency Readiness Lab while working shifts as a pediatric emergency physician at Ste-Justine Hospital.

Woman leans on fence, one arm propped up on it.


“The security obsession has eroded our social fabric,” she continued. “The Ebola crisis in West Africa, the hospital bombing in Kunduz” — in which 42 people were killed in the 2015 U.S. bombing of an Afghanistan hospital operated by Médecins sans frontières — “and the migrant crisis are important stories to tell. All three topics are news today: there’s an Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo; there are hospitals being bombed in Ukraine, Sudan and the Gaza Strip on a daily basis; and we have a migrant crisis in which migrants are being treated as existential threats to our communities.”


Liu was inspired to become a doctor as a teen after reading Albert Camus’s The Plague and Et la paix, docteur? by humanitarian surgeon Jean-Louis Willem.

“These works planted the seed of humanitarian medicine in my adolescent mind,” she writes in Ebola, Bombs, and Migrants. 


Liu was intentional in not wanting to make the memoir all about her but rather to share what she witnessed and learned, and yet her deep-rooted empathy and strong moral compass shine through in every page.


She begins with a bracingly honest look at her many years with Médecins sans frontières, offering a critical account of her time heading the organization, detailing the power struggles and infighting that took place as MSF grew and its influence in global affairs increased.


“I struggled with this part,” Liu admitted, “but my co-author said, ‘If you don’t explain the ecosystem you were navigating and how it made things difficult but a bit like a family, people might not understand the nuances.’ People have no clue that this is the world of Médecins sans frontières. We’re not saviours who go in, or very important people, we’re just human beings trying to do a little bit somewhere else.”


Liu tapped into that humanity during her second campaign to head Médecins sans frontières in 2013 following an unsuccessful first attempt. She shares an excerpt from her letter of intent, in which she wrote: “What keeps me up at night regarding MSF? I stay awake when I have the feeling that we are losing sight of our primary goal to treat patients in crisis contexts.”


That mantra guided her next six years as president as she worked to bring the sprawling organization’s various branches onto the same page while remaining focused on the urgency of the work being done on the ground.


“We were in a sequence of institutional growth,” she said. “Sometimes when you go through institutional growth, people forget why you have the institution — to care for patients, not for your headquarters in Geneva. The reason you exist is because of the patient in the Democratic Republic of Congo or in Sudan who needs an operation or to be treated for malaria. Our patient is our northern star, or our southern star. We should never lose track of that.”


Médecins sans frontières has grown exponentially since Liu stepped down in 2019 and now has an annual operating budget of €2.6 billion ($4.1 billion Canadian).

“It’s one of the biggest independent international NGOs in war zones,” Liu said. “I think it’s an incredible organization that does good for many people in crises.”

Liu hopes the spirit behind that mission comes through in her book. And she hopes to inspire readers regarding their own power to create change, despite the challenges.


“I want people to remember that everyone has agency,” she said. “Every single action is worth it. In my closing chapter, I talk to children in the emergency room at Ste-Justine who come in saying, ‘I don’t want to live. You’re handing me a really f—ed up planet.’ I hear them. I felt the same when I was six years old and there were simulations of nuclear attacks and we were hiding under our desks. I remember writing to the president of the United States and the U.S.S.R. back then.


“I want to tell young people it’s worth giving it a try, to not give up because it makes a difference. It may be an imperfect solution to an outsized problem, but it still makes a difference in someone’s life.”


More information


Elsewhere

No comments:

Post a Comment